top of page
Search

“I Don’t Need Help”: When an Aging Parent Refuses Support

Writer: Ben Lewis
Ben Lewis
2h
7 min read

The art of opening a side door

“I don’t need a babysitter.”

I’ve heard some version of that sentence more times than I can count since I started Engage As You Age in 2009. And the person saying it is usually right. They don’t need a babysitter. They need something much harder to prescribe: a reason to get dressed, a person who’s glad to see them, an afternoon that feels like their own.

If you’ve ever had a small child who wouldn’t take their medicine, you know the applesauce trick: you offer it with something they already like. Much of my work is a version of that. The connection is the medicine. The applesauce is the art, the music, the walk, the project — the thing that makes someone want to open the door.

Why “I’m fine” makes so much sense

There’s an “ick” to being helped, and I don’t blame anyone for feeling it. Friendship is supposed to be chosen. When it arrives on a schedule, arranged by your children, it can feel like a verdict: you can’t manage anymore.

Many of the people I meet are in the early stages of memory loss. They’re frightened, grieving and working very hard to hold on to the life they know. Denial and defensiveness aren’t stubbornness. They’re what holding on looks like.

This fall I met a woman in Marin I’ll call Dorothy, who has always been the one in charge. She’s been diagnosed with Alzheimer’s and doesn’t believe it, and anything on a schedule makes her anxious. Her family put it simply: for her, someone just showing up is easier than a plan.

That’s the whole philosophy. Don’t announce a program. Show up.

When the front door stays shut

Over the years I’ve watched loving families try the direct route, and it rarely goes the way they hope. “We’ve arranged for someone to come keep you company” is heard as “you’re failing,” and the person digs in.

Sometimes the door never opens at all. This fall a care manager in Santa Rosa referred a man whose partner badly needed a break, and warned me that getting him to agree to anything would be the hard part; the partner never called. I also hear from husbands and wives, from San Jose to Napa, who have cared for a spouse with dementia or Parkinson’s for years. They reach out on a hard night, we plan a call, and then nothing. I don’t read that as a lack of interest. Asking for help, even for someone you love, can feel like admitting something you’re not ready to say out loud.

Side doors that work

What works far more often is giving the visit a reason to exist that has nothing to do with need.

A gift to someone else. A man in San Mateo I’ll call Howard wasn’t interested in “a companion.” But when we talked about his wife being able to spend a full day with her sister without rushing home, he lit up. He also liked the idea of someone who drives, to get him out exploring again, and who could finally make the TV remote and his tablet make sense. Helping her is what got him to yes.

A shared passion. A woman in Berkeley I’ll call Miriam wanted to take cello lessons again, and her family worried that would compete with her Engage visits. I told them honestly: if she wants formal lessons, hire a teacher. If she wants to play with someone, laugh, schmooze and connect around music, that’s where we fit. The music is the applesauce.

A project with a purpose. Some people open the door for something tangible: figuring out the smartphone the grandkids gave them, organizing decades of photos, or an oral history project that records their stories for future generations. The visit is about the accomplishment. The friendship grows quietly alongside it.

Their own interests, exactly as they are. A daughter in Palo Alto wanted her mother, I’ll call her Joan, to have a say in what happened next. Joan isn’t looking for someone with a lot of energy and a list of things she should be doing. She loves her online puzzles and word games. The right person for her is grounded and patient, and might start simply by sitting down and playing along.

A new friend, introduced gently. And sometimes there’s no project at all. Sometimes a person simply needs a new friend to walk into their life. Rather than a formal start date, the first meeting might be coffee with someone who shares their love of opera, or an introduction through someone they already trust.

Where the fib stops

Families ask me about the gentle part of this work, so I’ll be clear about it. Sometimes we soften how a visit is introduced. We lead with the shared interest, not the arrangement. But there are lines I hold:

  • What we lead with is always true: the shared love of music, the photo project, the person who genuinely wants to meet them.

  • We never mislead anyone about their health, their safety or their care.

  • The older person’s own wishes count. Someone who can weigh this for themselves gets to decide, and a clear no is respected.

  • Families know what we’re doing, and we plan the introduction together.

The goal is to take the stigma out of the first meeting, not to talk anyone into something. The introduction can be gentle. Everything after it has to be real.

When the answer is “not yet”

Not every side door opens. This fall I met with a man in Mill Valley I’ll call Leonard, who loves jazz and history, and his wife. She was enthusiastic. He thought about it and decided he didn’t want anyone new right now. We offered something smaller, help turning the thousands of photos on his phone into a digital frame, and agreed to check back after the new year.

That’s not a failure. “Not yet” is an answer, and honoring it is how you keep the door from locking.

What we’re really after

The goal isn’t to get someone to accept help. It’s to help them rediscover something they want.

When that happens, I get to watch the part of this work I never get tired of. Someone who insisted they were fine starts telling stories nobody has asked about in years. Their shoulders drop. They’re calmer. They light up when the doorbell rings.

If you’re worried about someone who keeps saying they don’t need anything, start with what they love. And be gentle with yourself too. Finding the right side door takes patience, and sometimes a few tries. If you’d like to think it through with someone who has helped thousands of families find theirs, I’m always glad to talk. Talk with Ben about your family.

Cheat sheet: starting visits for someone with dementia who says no

Print this, or forward it to your siblings. Use only details that are true.

  • Instead of “We’ve hired a companion for you,” try: “I met someone who loves jazz as much as you do. Can I bring her by for coffee?”

  • Instead of “You can’t be alone so much anymore,” try: “I’d feel better knowing you had company on Tuesdays. Would you try it for me?”

  • Instead of “Someone will come every week,” try: “Want to try one afternoon and see how it goes?”

  • Instead of “It’s for your memory,” try: “She grew up in the city too. I think you’d enjoy trading stories.”

  • Instead of “You need help with your phone,” try: “Could she help us get the grandkids’ photos onto your phone?”

  • Instead of arguing when they say no, try: “That’s fine. Let’s think about it.” Then try a different door in a few weeks.

  • Instead of leading with the arrangement, try leading with the shared interest. Families can handle scheduling and logistics in the background.

What we do at Engage

  • Meet the person first, in a relaxed setting, before anyone uses the word “visits.”

  • Match on a genuine shared interest, not just availability.

  • Ben comes to the first visit to make the introduction feel natural.

  • Start small: one afternoon, one project, one outing.

  • Keep the same person every week, so trust can build.

Questions families ask

How do I get a parent with dementia to accept help?

Lead with something they enjoy, not with the help. A shared interest, a project or a small favor for you is far easier to say yes to than “care.” Keep the first step small, let them choose the day or the activity, and if they say no, wait and try a different approach.

Is it okay to tell a white lie to get my parent to try companion visits?

Many families soften how the first meeting is introduced, and dementia care professionals sometimes call this therapeutic fibbing. Keep it to the introduction: lead with something true, like a shared interest, and never mislead someone about their health, safety or care. If your parent can weigh the decision, their no counts.

What should I say when introducing a companion to someone with dementia?

Introduce the person, not the service. “This is Maya. She loves the opera too” works far better than “This is your companion.” Mention what they have in common and let the conversation start there.

What if my parent refuses after the first visit?

It usually means the fit or the framing was off, not that the idea is wrong. Try a different person, a different interest or a shorter visit. Sometimes waiting a few weeks and coming back through a different door makes all the difference.

How long does it take someone with dementia to get comfortable with a new companion?

For many people it takes a few visits with the same person on a regular day. Consistency matters more than length. A predictable weekly visit with someone familiar builds trust faster than frequent visits with different people.

What’s the difference between companion care and home care?

Home care agencies focus on hands-on help: bathing, dressing, medications and household tasks. Companion care is about connection: conversation, shared interests, outings and time with someone who helps a person feel calmer and more like themselves. Many families have both. Engage focuses only on the companionship, matching each person with someone who shares what they love. See our services.

Ben Lewis founded Engage As You Age in 2009. Engage matches older adults across the San Francisco Bay Area with Activity Specialists who share their interests, for regular one-on-one visits at home or out in the world. Learn more at www.EngageAsYouAge.com.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page